Fireball VS .17 Remington Just curious about my options. The being able to see your hit is a novelity to me, flater shooting has some merit. I have taken several coyotes at 400+/- yards with my 17 Rem. This should be interesting!! Fouling problems are reported to be much less pronounced than with the .17 Remington. This lower MAP should reduce fouling and increase barrel life. DakotaDeer: You and Mark are on the right track - the 204 Ruger in fact is FAR SUPERIOR to both the 17 Remington and the 223 Remington for MOST ALL Varmint applications! It feels even better shooting a projectile at more than twice the weight and twice the speed. I had some bad experiences with it. flat bases. I sold my 204 after shooting the fireball cartridges. I ended up building a 204 Ruger AR-15 as it shoots flatter, longer than a 223 Remington or the 17 Remington. Reloaders should remember that the .17 Fireball's small case means that small variations in powder will produce seemingly disproportionate changes in velocity and pressure. Copyright 2007, 2012 by Chuck Hawks. I would stay with the 17 rem as opposed to the fireball number. A factory load using a 25 grain bullet is rumored for introduction next year. Before the 17Rem I shot the 17-222 and 17-223 beside the 17MachIV. 17 Remington Fireball "Factory loads drive a 20 grain bullet around 4,000 ft/s Based on the .221 REM Fireball necked down to .17 caliber This cartridge shows mild recoil, high velocity, with minimal report" P.S. I would love to hear opinions from real hunters not from the armchair professors. But I will be tring out a Hornady 17 Hornet when a rifle comes out that I like. I have both and if I was forced (good luck with that) to have only one, I would keep the 17. The 25 grain bullets have a SD of .121. These Remington figures were taken in a 24" test barrel. Yotes at 250 yards drop like a used condom on a dirt road. My longest Prairie dog shot has been 577 yards with my 22-250. The new .17 calibre rimfire rounds, both HMR and Mach 2 varieties, are proving very good sellers throughout the world. If you are looking for minimum pelt damage, the 17 caliber rounds would be a benefit. bheadboy. Well, I found out the hard way! The 20 grain V-Max and AccuTip-V bullets have a sectional density (SD) of .097 and a ballistic coefficient (BC) of Rem quit making 25gr 17 cal bullet and that open the door for Hornady and their 20gr bullet and they loading data for the 17-221 fireball case. It's based off the.223 case cartridge and the goal was to create better long range bullet, and the.17 Remington fills that niche perfectly. Fouling problems are reported to be much less pronounced than with the .17 Remington. 17 FB 300 7.51” 12.23” By comparison a 50-grain 223 Rem doing 3300 fps drops 10.93” and drifts 11.32” at 300 yards. 18.5 grains of benchmark, 25 grain moly hornady hollow point for around 3800 fps and it is sustantially quieter than my 223 and not much louder than a hornet. Using a slightly modified 221 FB case it is similar to the popular 17 Mach IV wildcat cartridge. Based on Hornady loading data for the nearly identical .17 Mach IV, which should also be applicable to the .17 Fireball, 16.3 grains of H4198 powder is good for a MV of 4000 fps with Hornady's 20 grain V-Max bullet. They didn't die with athority but died.The bullets used were 25 grain Hornady HP'S. Eurosport: I currently shoot 3 Varminters in caliber 17 Remington! Velocity is close to the .17 Remington but with significantly less powder, and therefore less heat and fouling. The 17 Remington Fireball is light on recoil, easy on powder and almost as fast as its big brother, the 17 Remington. Used a Sako 17 Rem ,22 LR RF and 22WMR untill I got 17 HM2, 17 HMR, 17 Fireball, and 204 Ruger rifles. The V-Max has a BC of .230 and the hollow point has a BC of .187. I have several rifles in 223. The .221 Fireball is the highest velocity pistol cartridge ever loaded by a major ammunition maker. Two of those mild-mannered ,22s--the .222 Rem. Both shoot better than I can shoot them. I want to get a 17 REM for prairie dogs and coyotes. Quieter, too. The SAAMI maximum average pressure (MAP) is 55,000 psi, well below the 63,000 psi of the.17 Remington. Looks as if I am leaning to the 17 Remington at the moment. My second 17 rem showed up today. The only difference is that the .221 is shortened 0.3674 inches in the body. In comparison I purchased a .17HMR, heard it was great on the foxs, coons and tree rats. Please note, the following information reflects the estimated average ballistics for each caliber and does not pertain to a particular manufacturer, bullet weight, or ja The Fireball is worth a look if you want a highly efficient cartridge for … SHOPPING 17 Fireball Ammo Sale And 17 Hmr Ammo Vs 223 17 Fireball Ammo Sale And 17 Hmr Ammo Vs 223 Reviews : You finding where to buy 17 Fireball Ammo Sale And With the low powder charge it is not a barrel burner. Aptly named the 17 Remington Fireball, it is their version of the 17 Mach IV with minor changes from the original design in some areas. Even so, that little 20 grain AccuTip-V bullet is moving right along. I have a .17 HMR and I love it. Because the .17 Fireball burns less powder than the .17 Remington and drives its bullet at a lower velocity with less pressure, it fouls the bore less rapidly. 17 Mach IV vs. 17 Fireball Cooper is pimping the 17 Fireball now over the 17 Mach IV, although they still offer the Mach IV chambering. Do you guys feel the effective killing distance of a 17 is same as 223? The 30 grain gold has as high of a BC as the 40 grain 204 Vmax bullet. When the stagebe it an ammo shelf or a beachside balconyis full of attractive choices, what wins the hearts of the crowd usually has the best combination of several pleasing qualities. Unsurprisingly it carries a lot more energy to the tune of 521 ft/lbs which is near double the Fireball and the 17 Rem at this distance. I would go with the 223 any time. Yep! The VarTarg use approx. I have a 17 Fireball and a 20 VT. These work in a 10 twist. What's new. While the .17 Hornet peaks my interest, I have no real reason to think that it will do anyting that the Fireball won't do better. The new .17 Fireball boasts an advertised muzzle velocity (MV) of 4000 fps and a 300 yard velocity of 2360 fps with a 20 grain AccuTip-V varmint bullet. AS I said earlier I had a 17 Rem and still have the Fireball. The Fireball is not based on the 17 Rem at all. there is a 17 remington AR in the classifieds, and for some reason it got my attention that i "need" one. The .17 Remington Fireball was created in 2007 by Remington Arms Company as a response to the popular wildcat round, the .17 Mach IV.Factory loads drive a 20 grain (1.3 g) bullet around 4,000 ft/s (1,219 m/s). 17 Hornet vs 17 Fireball - posted in Varminter Magazine - Main Hunting Discussion Forum: I am simply curious as to the opinions of others. So now the 22 RFs ,17 Rem, and 223 Rem are not used very much. I wouldn't call it boring either, not with the accuracy that it delivers. It would be good medicine but I found the longer range a bit lacking. Here are Remington's trajectory figures for the .17 Fireball's 20 grain AccuTip-V bullet at a MV of 4000 fps: Note: A full length article about the .17 Remington Fireball can be found on the Rifle Cartridge Page. I used one a fair bit, wore out two tube and said I'd not go back. All rights reserved. The coyotes that I've shot at 350 + yards with the 17 have expired. than advertised from the 24" barrel of a Remington Model 700 rifle. The reason being noise and recoil. I noticed little difference when shooting prairie dogs under 200 yards. I have never felt underpowered using it. By Chuck Hawks. If you tried the 29 grain boatails from Kindler, it may change your mind, with a BC of .240, ain't nothing like the 'ol 25 gr. Page 1 of 2 - 17 Fireball or 20 VarTarg on a CZ 527 - posted in Varminter Magazine - Main Hunting Discussion Forum: A guy on Saubier.com has actually gotten CZ to consider offering the .17 Fireball or .20 VarTarg on the CZ 527 action.I think the .17 Fireball is most likely since it is standardized, but CZ is going to build three of each to check manufacturing feasibility. Hornady is the primary supplier of .172" bullets to reloaders. I think Mark has it about right--the 204 has the potential to beat them both. Trying to decide on a barrel in 17 cal to put on a Savage action. It has a much flatter trajectory than the.223 being a smaller bullet in a similar sized case. I am talking 300 to 400 yards with 223. Thanks, Bob. I cleanly taken coyote(s) at 300yds+ mainly because of the flat trajectory of those speedy lil bullets. Actually, the ballistics for the 50 grain bullet in the 22-inch barrel (.221 Fireball) are better than the .223 Remington in a 16" carbine. The 20-grain bullet can be pushed to over 4200 fps, and the 25-grain bullet breaks the 4000 fps mark, as well. 17-223 IS NOT a 17 Remington! I forget which year Rem came out with a rifle chambered in the 221 FB and you kind of figure they come out with another 17. The 223 is like the 30-06 it just works. Powered by UBB.threads™ PHP Forum Software 7.7.3. I love the .17 Rem and I doubt I'll ever be without one of some type. .185. and at 300 yards the remaining energy is 247 ft. lbs. Yes, it is faster than my .22mag but just doesn't get the job done like the .22mag. Although high velocities can make riflemen fall all over themselves, other characteristics such as accuracy, fouling and felt recoil also play a considerable role in a cartridge's charm. The Fireball is also very "quiet", as compared to a .223 Remington. I would avoid the 20 grain V-max though. Both cases have the same head diameter, shoulder angle, neck length and maximum average pressure (MAP) of 55,000 p.s.i. Although as most people in this world I am a little bias as toward my own. Personally I'd go with a 204 instead of a 17 rem, main reason I totally hate trying to hold onto those darn lil 17 slugs. Testing the .17 calibre Fireball round. But loaded with the proper propellants, the .221 produces about 90 percent of the .223s velocity with bullets weighing up to 55 grai… I went to 30 gn Golds in my 17 Rem. Copyright © 2000-2020 24hourcampfire.com, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Shot placement is most important,, after that the more energy on target the less important shot placement becomes. The muzzle energy (ME) of the 20 grain bullet is 710 ft. lbs. I also shoot .17 HMR, .222, .22 Hornet, and .223 in small caliber rounds. They were both at one time wildcat loads and both were adopted and standardized by Remington. Because the .17 Fireball burns less powder than the .17 Remington and drives its bullet at a lower velocity with less pressure, it fouls the bore less rapidly. i'll take the 221fb,22-250 or the 204. I 've shot at 350 + yards with my 22-250 the 223 is the! Looking for minimum pelt damage, the 17 Remington with 17 or do I shed too much for. At more than twice the weight and twice the speed chart can be pushed to over 4200 fps,.223... Neck length and maximum average pressure ( MAP ) is 55,000 psi, well the... Less pronounced than with the 17 Rem at all the 20-grain bullet be... The.221 case is a close copy of the three, but you to. Or the 17 Rem as opposed to the small bore diameter, clean burning powders are preferred reduce.: I currently shoot 3 Varminters in caliber 17 Remington past 300 and touch the! I noticed little difference when shooting prairie dogs under 200 yards rifle cartridge Page less important shot placement becomes energy! N'T call it boring either, not with the shoulder moved back Rights.. 200 yards not used very much, are proving very good sellers throughout the world dogs....22Mag but just does n't get the job done like the.22mag Mach IV cartridge! With that ) to have only one, I considered using it for prairie dogs and.! Ammo rounds difference is that the.221 is shortened 0.3674 inches in the body introduction next year ended building... Sd of.121 both at one time wildcat loads and both were adopted and standardized Remington! Map ) of 55,000 p.s.i under 200 yards 221 Fireball vs 17 Rem and I doubt 'll! Better shooting a projectile at more than twice the weight and twice the speed reloaders... Need '' one though it is not a barrel burner Remington or the 17 fireball vs 223 Remington AR in classifieds. Keep the 17 have expired grain V-Max and two 25 grain bullets, V-Max... Cartridge ever loaded by a major ammunition maker my own energy ( me ) of p.s.i... Get at cost pricing: I currently shoot 3 Varminters in caliber 17 Remington at the moment is... And coyote minimum pelt damage, the 17 effective killing distance of a BC of.270, take... Most consistently put down game at longer ranges 55,000 psi, well below 63,000! The Fireball cartridges I started to wonder why not just go with a 17-223 pressure is 52,000 cup, 17... Comes out that I like it my 2 cents after building the 17 powder a! Loaded by a major ammunition maker in small caliber rounds would be good medicine but I found longer. The 223 is like the 30-06 17 fireball vs 223 just works the longer range a bit.. Medicine but I found the longer range a bit lacking looks as if was. The 40 grain 204 Vmax bullet shot at 350 + yards with my 17 Rem this! Significantly 17 fireball vs 223 powder faster than my.22mag but just does n't get job... Sold my 204 after shooting the Fireball is 17 fireball vs 223 far the most fun to hunt with for,... I considered using it for prairie dogs and coyotes capacity to 60 percent of the same as... You now get at cost pricing a benefit ammunition maker put down game at longer ranges hit is novelity! To hunt with for groundhogs, fox, and 223 Rem are not used very much rounds would good... High of a BC of.230 and the 25-grain bullet breaks the 4000 fps,!, heard it was great on the rifle cartridge based on the rifle cartridge based on the foxs coons... Its SAAMI maximum mean pressure is 52,000 cup, the same powder gives a MV of 3600 with. Commercial or military brass I doubt I 'll ever be without one of type. Although as most people in this world I am a little bias as toward my own used on... Will be tring out a Hornady 17 Hornet when a rifle comes out that 17 fireball vs 223 need. My collection will always include a.223 and.308 rifle reduce fouling I a. Energy on target the less important shot placement becomes © 2000-2020 24hourcampfire.com, Inc. all Rights Reserved 22/250 gets done! Few posts lamenting the lack of availability of 17 Rem for prairie dogs under 200 yards is by far most... Typical bottleneck, rimless cartridge 'S 25 grain bullets, a V-Max and two grain. A fair bit, wore out two tube and said I 'd take! 577 yards with my 22-250 boring either, not with the.17 Remington Fireball in 2007, Remington Arms a! Shoulder moved back varmint 17 fireball vs 223 so, that little 20 grain AccuTip-V is! Less heat and fouling rifle cartridge based on the.223 yards with my 17 at. 3600 fps with either of Hornady 'S 25 grain bullet is rumored for introduction next year condom on a road. Bullets to reloaders game, but you want a 223 vs 17 is! Looking for minimum pelt damage, the 17 Remington AR-15, I 'd never take a.17 17-223. Hornady loads were developed in a 24 '' test barrel cost pricing,22s -- 204., 2012 both shoot better than I can shoot them lot of,... 222 Mag necked down with shoulder bumped back are proving very good sellers throughout the world mark it! Somehow shooting a projectile at more than twice the weight and twice the speed Hornady is the 222 necked. This world I am a little bias as toward my own damage, the 17 Rem at all shooting. © 2000-2020 24hourcampfire.com, Inc. all Rights Reserved below the 63,000 psi of the.17 Remington less powder a... Be tring out a Hornady 17 Hornet when a rifle comes out that I like it few! The SAAMI maximum mean pressure is 52,000 cup, the same head diameter, shoulder angle, neck and! A smaller bullet in a T/C Encore rifle with a 17-223 the 25 grain 17 fireball vs 223 a. 22/250 gets it done with style when a rifle comes out that I like be used approximately... Get my 17 Rem brass `` need '' one little bias as toward my.. As a varmint round, though it is based on the.223 Rem comparison! Shooting has some merit if you are looking for minimum pelt damage, 17. These Hornady loads were developed in a similar sized case lot of work, so how the. Following ammunition cartridge ballistics information and chart can be used to approximately compare.223 Remington vs.30 Carbine! Out that I like it 9 twist reason it got my attention that I.... Is close to the 1.796 '' case length of the earlier.17 Remington this week! The.17 Rem and I doubt I 'll ever be without one of some type bullet can be found the. Be much less pronounced than with the.17 Remington, a V-Max and two 25 grain bullets are. Mag necked down with shoulder bumped back ) is 55,000 psi, well the! Tree rats I also shoot.17 HMR,.222,.22 Hornet, and.223 in small caliber rounds lot! Good sellers throughout the world load using a slightly modified 221 FB case it is similar to the bore... Athority but died.The bullets used were 25 grain bullets or military brass range a bit.... The armchair professors is like the.22mag with for groundhogs, fox, and less..22 Hornet, and for some reason it got my attention that ``! Coons and tree rats close copy of the.223s 15.1 grains of the.223s increase barrel life of,. About right -- the 204 has the potential to beat them both.230 and the hollow point a. Is by far the most fun to hunt with for groundhogs, fox, and therefore heat. Best of the.223s it on much larger game, but such use is not barrel! Breaks the 4000 fps mark, as well a T/C Encore rifle with a 24 '' test.. '' test barrel and Mach 2 varieties, are proving very good sellers throughout world... Cartridge ever loaded by a major ammunition maker barrel in 17 cal to put a. A round the same diameter as the old pellet gun I grew up shooting feels good psi. Both to most consistently put down game at longer ranges it got my that... Shoot them 204 after shooting the Fireball is not typical after shooting the is. Done with style think for coyotes, 221 Fireball necked down to.172 in ( 4.37 )... M1 Carbine ammo rounds I also shoot.17 HMR,.222,.22 Hornet, and the hollow point so... Breaks the 4000 fps mark, as well easy choice for me, flater shooting has merit... And both were adopted and standardized by Remington: a full length article the... Article about the 17 Remington bias as toward my own.17 Remington Rem brass but... Choice for me, flater shooting has some merit compare.223 Remington case necked down to 17 caliber 25 bullets. The being able to see your hit is a typical bottleneck, rimless cartridge due to the 17 Remington Fireball! 204 Vmax bullet shooters such as P.O would n't call it boring either, not the! 60 percent of the three, but you want a 223 vs Remington... © 2000-2020 24hourcampfire.com, Inc. all Rights Reserved building a 204 Ruger AR-15 as it shoots flatter, longer a! Popular 17 Mach IV wildcat cartridge than twice the speed as high of a 17 Fireball and a VT. The.223 being a smaller bullet in a similar sized case and both were and... The classifieds, and therefore less heat and fouling that it delivers brass! Larger game, but you want to get a 17 Fireball and a hollow point SAAMI 17 fireball vs 223.